Public Statistics – Electoral advertising and campaign litigation in the 1st round of Brazilian elections (2018, 2022 and 2026)

Data from the Open Data Portal of the Superior Electoral Court (TSE, “Processual” group) and from the DataJud/CNJ Public API, extracted on 14 and 15/10/2026. Companion page: the 2nd round. Frozen version accompanying the article: v1.0, TSE data load of 14/10/2026, in Portuguese (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23441914).

Figures in the text refer to the TSE data load of 14/10/2026.

Who rules on electoral campaign and advertising complaints at the Superior Electoral Court (TSE)

In the electoral courts (both the Regional Electoral Courts and the TSE), complaints (representações), claims (reclamações) and right-of-reply requests fall within the jurisdiction of auxiliary judges appointed for that purpose, and appeals against their rulings must be decided by the full Court, under paragraphs 3 and 4 of Article 96 of the Elections Law (Law 9.504/1997). Nevertheless, the Court’s President and Vice-President took this jurisdiction upon themselves, contrary to TSE Resolution 23.608/2019, which requires auxiliary judges to be appointed from among the Court’s substitute members (Art. 2, II and § 4), and with no recorded collegiate decision.

Through TSE Ordinance (Portaria) 235 of 20 May 2026 (published in the Electronic Justice Gazette, DJE, on 22 May), the newly sworn-in President Nunes Marques appointed Justice André Mendonça, already serving as Vice-President, to one of the three auxiliary judge seats on the advertising panel and, in the same act, included himself in the assignment of cases on the matter. Until then, only Justice Estela Aranha, appointed in 2025 under Justice Cármen Lúcia’s presidency of the TSE, was formally assigned to the panel, since Justice Vera Lúcia Santana Araújo, also appointed at the end of 2025 under Justice Cármen Lúcia, left the TSE in February 2026.

Only on 7 October, after the first-round vote, did the Court’s President appoint substitute Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze Oliveira, who joined the random-assignment roster alongside Justice Estela Aranha, Justice André Mendonça and Nunes Marques himself. The Presidency’s participation in case assignment is not unprecedented: in the 2nd round of 2022, TSE Ordinance 1.007/2022 included then-President Alexandre de Moraes in the assignment of advertising complaints. The difference lies in its scope and its outcome. In 2022, the Presidency joined only in the 2nd round, the Vice-President did not take part, and in the 1st round the President and Vice-President were reporting justices in 5 of 200 cases (2.5%); in the 2nd round, Moraes’s chambers received the same share of each campaign’s cases (18.0% of Bolsonaro’s and 18.2% of Lula’s) and decided all 44. In 2026, the Presidency and the Vice-Presidency have been part of case assignment since the start of the campaign calendar and concentrated 398 of the 598 first-round cases (66.6%), and the President’s chambers received cases unevenly across the campaigns, holding on to those filed by Lula against Flávio.

Reporting justices of complaints, right-of-reply requests and notices of irregularity in the 1st round

ElectionTSE PresidentVice-PresidentCasesWith the President or Vice-President as reporting justice%Main reporting justices
2018Rosa WeberLuís Roberto Barroso28920.7%Sergio Banhos (95), Carlos Horbach (83), Isabel Gallotti (68)
2022Alexandre de MoraesRicardo Lewandowski20052.5%Cármen Lúcia (57), Maria Claudia Bucchianeri (53), Paulo de Tarso Sanseverino (37)
2026Nunes MarquesAndré Mendonça59839866.6%Nunes Marques (209), André Mendonça (189), Estela Aranha (141)

Original-jurisdiction cases at the TSE (complaint, special complaint, right of reply and notice of irregularity in advertising) filed from 20/07 to election day of the 1st round; current reporting justice according to SIG/TSE, data load of 14/10/2026. President and Vice-President as of the 1st-round election day. Legal sources: Law 9.504/1997, Art. 96, §§ 3 and 4; TSE Resolution 23.608/2019, Art. 2, II and § 4 (and, in 2018, TSE Resolution 23.547/2017, Art. 2); TSE Ordinance 235/2026 (DJE-TSE No. 81, 22/05/2026).

1. Litigation grew, especially at the TSE

Cases filed from 20/07 to the 1st-round election day. Left: the whole Electoral Justice system; right: advertising, right-of-reply, notice-of-irregularity, interim-relief, removal-from-office (cassação) and appeal cases at the TSE, excluding appeals on candidate registration.

Electoral Justice, all case types

TSE, campaign cases

2. The Regional Electoral Courts absorbed the increase; the TSE slowed down

Share of cases with a first decision, judgment or court ruling within 3 and within 10 days of filing. Three days approximate the 72 hours set by Art. 58, § 2, of Law 9.504/1997.

Decided within 3 days

Decided within 10 days

Absolute numbers

ElectionCourtCasesWithin 3 days%Within 10 days%

3. Speed by campaign and TSE presidency

Original-jurisdiction TSE cases filed by one main presidential campaign against the other in the 1st round. For 2022, Moraes’s presidency only. Differences are not significant in 2018 and 2022. In 2026, the raw 3-day difference is significant, but it ceases to be when each reporting justice is compared with himself or herself.

ElectionTSE PresidentFiled byCasesWithin 3 days%Within 10 days%p 3 days (raw)p 3 days (by reporting justice and case type)

4. Chambers in 2026: the difference comes from case assignment

Cases decided among those against each campaign, by effective reporting justice (author of the first decision in SIG). Within each Justice’s chambers the two sides are close; Estela Aranha, the fastest chambers, received 80 cases against Lula and 38 against Flávio. Excluded: 33 cases reassigned to Bellizze after the 1st round, none decided by 14/10, and 6 with other Justices.

Reporting justiceRespondent campaignCasesWithin 3 days%Within 10 days%In DataJudInjunction request ruled onInjunction granted

5. Preliminary injunctions: the asymmetry appears in 2026

Share of cases with a ruling on the request for a preliminary injunction, among those found in DataJud (TPU codes 339, 892 and 792). In 2026 the difference holds when controlling for reporting justice and case type (Mantel-Haenszel, p = 0.008). In 2022, under Moraes, it is not significant. DataJud does not hold these cases for 2018.

ElectionTSE PresidentFiled byCasesIn DataJudInjunction request ruled on%Grantedp (Fisher)

6. All chambers, by TSE presidency

Share of each campaign’s cases received by each Justice’s chambers in the 1st round, under the presidencies of Rosa Weber (2018), Alexandre de Moraes (2022) and Nunes Marques (2026). The highlighted row is the TSE President’s chambers. Chambers with fewer than 3 cases are grouped as “Other chambers”. Chambers: author of the first decision recorded in SIG; if no decision, the current reporting justice. Data from frozen version v1.0-1T (TSE data load of 14/10/2026).

Summary

Campaign cases at the TSE, 2026 — in 2022: — · in 2018: —
TSE: cases decided within 3 days, 2026 — in 2022: — · Regional Courts in 2026: —
Injunction requests ruled on by the TSE in the 1st round of 2026, among cases found in DataJud
— in Flávio Bolsonaro’s cases against Lula
×
— in Lula’s cases against Flávio Bolsonaro
The difference is statistically significant even when comparing within each Justice’s chambers (Mantel-Haenszel, p = 0.008). In 2022, under Moraes, there was no significant difference.

Method and sources

  • Main source: TSE Open Data Portal, “Processual” group (files on electoral cases, decisions and parties), extracted on 14 and 15/10/2026. Preliminary injunctions: DataJud/CNJ Public API, queried in October 2026, covering about 64% of the 2026 cases.
  • Time frame: from filing to the first decision-making act (decision, judgment or court ruling), excluding procedural orders. Cases with no decision count as undecided.
  • Campaigns identified by their main parties: candidates, national coalition or party federation, national party and campaign taxpayer number (CNPJ).
  • Tests: Fisher’s exact test (raw comparison) and Mantel-Haenszel stratified by effective reporting justice and case type. p below 0.05 is highlighted.
  • Legal provisions: Law 9.504/1997, Arts. 8, 58, § 2, and 96, §§ 3 and 4; TSE Resolutions 23.547/2017 (2018) and 23.608/2019, Art. 2, II and § 4; TSE Ordinance 235/2026.

Media coverage

Celso de Oliveira Santos

Lawyer and consultant to public, private and non-profit organizations. Law professor and postdoctoral researcher in the Graduate Program of the Faculty of Law of the Rio de Janeiro State University (UERJ). LL.M. from the University of São Paulo (USP) and Ph.D. from UERJ (funded by FAPERJ) in International and Comparative Law. Coordinator of the Specialization Course in International Law at CEPED/UERJ. Researcher in the DGAPA PAPIIT IN309526 Project “Cambios dentro de la Democracia: retrocesos, resistencias y resiliencias”, at the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM). Member of the Latin American Studies Association and of the International Law Committees of the São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro sections of the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB).

Study: “Como explicar a letargia do TSE nas eleições mais judicializadas da história do Brasil?” (How to explain the TSE’s lethargy in the most litigated elections in Brazil’s history?). Open data from the TSE and DataJud/CNJ, processed by the author. Data and code for the article version: DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23441914.